Designers Say These Holiday Decor Mistakes Turn Off Guests

This article was prepared from the source material provided, which included designer interviews and recommendations.

Hosts hoping to make a good impression this holiday season may want to rethink their decorations, according to two interior designers who spoke about the details guests notice most. Hayley McAteer, an interior designer and co-founder of Cushee, and Kellie Sirna, founder of the Dallas-based firm Studio 11 Design, identified several common missteps and offered alternatives.

Credit: Per Magnus Persson / Getty Images

McAteer pointed to low-quality accessories as a frequent problem. Bows or ribbons with frayed edges can undermine an otherwise polished display, she said. She recommended choosing higher-quality materials such as fabric or velvet, which look more refined and hold up over time.

An empty entryway is another missed opportunity. Because it is the first space guests enter, McAteer said it should create a warm, ambient setting that sets the tone for the rest of the home. "The entryway is the first impression of your holiday spirit," she said. Simple additions like a seasonal doormat, a wreath, or lanterns with candles can make guests feel welcomed, she added.

Clashing color schemes can also create visual confusion. McAteer warned that mixing too many mismatched colors—such as neon lights with classic gold and silver ornaments—produces chaos rather than cohesion. She suggested limiting the palette to two or three complementary colors so the overall look feels unified.

Finally, overusing seasonal scents can overwhelm guests. McAteer advised against an excess of scented candles or potpourri, recommending instead subtle scents placed thoughtfully and spread out to keep the atmosphere inviting.

What to Do Instead

Sirna emphasized the role of sensory details in immersing guests in the holiday spirit. Candles or twinkle lights can evoke warmth and nostalgia, while playing holiday music on a speaker helps set the tone, she said.

Incorporating family heirlooms is another way to create a meaningful statement. Sentimental decorations passed down through generations can stir childhood memories and serve as natural conversation starters, according to Sirna.

She also encouraged personalizing store-bought items. For example, a garland brought indoors can be customized with bows, twinkle lights, fresh florals, or sparkly pine cones to make it stand out.

The designers' advice centers on intentional choices: quality over quantity, harmony over excess, and personal touches that make guests feel welcome.